Development Relationship Manager

Better TogetherNaples, FloridaRemote, On-siteFull-timeMid level, 2–5 yearsListed 38 minutes ago

Apply now

About this role

OVERVIEW

Better Together works to address the root causes of poverty, dependency, divorce, and child abuse by leveraging the power of the local church to provide struggling families with supportive relationships and meaningful work. With the right support, families can achieve independence, stay together, and thrive.

The Development Relationship Manager is responsible for managing the operational and relational components of donor development, including donor stewardship, cultivation, renewals, and engagement. This role oversees the donor pipeline, ensures accurate and timely donation processing and acknowledgments, coordinates personalized donor communications, and partners with leadership to develop and execute donor cultivation and retention strategies. The position also manages donor engagement initiatives, cultivation events, and the systems that keep donor relationships organized, active, and growing.

The ideal candidate is a relational, highly organized, and results-oriented professional who understands the importance of building lasting donor relationships. They are equally comfortable managing development systems and administrative details as they are coordinating meaningful donor engagement. They work collaboratively with Closers, Connectors, Executive Directors, Marketing, and organizational leadership to strengthen donor relationships and advance Better Together’s mission.

CULTURE AND FIT

At Better Together, we are a mission-first team that shows up with purpose, humility, and grit. Our culture is shaped by five core values that guide how we lead, how we serve, and how we grow. If these values reflect who you are and how you work, you may be a great fit for our team.

- We Love Others : We lead with empathy, humility, and integrity. We treat every person with dignity, make people feel seen and valued, and do what’s right even when it’s hard. Do you treat people with respect, no matter their background or behavior?
- Do you make decisions based on what’s best for others, not just yourself?

- We Choose Gratitude: Gratitude fuels our joy and shapes how we show up. We focus on what’s possible, not what’s missing. We uplift others, celebrate progress, and keep perspective—even in the tough seasons. Do you stay positive and solutions-focused when challenges arise?
- Do you regularly speak encouragement and appreciation to your teammates?

- We Are Ideal Team Players : We are hungry, humble, and people-smart. We take initiative, lift others up, and work wisely with all kinds of people. The best teams aren’t made of perfect people—they’re made of teachable ones. Do you take ownership and go the extra mile without being asked?
- Are you open to feedback and constantly looking for ways to grow?

- We Do Hard Things : We don’t quit when things get hard. We press in with courage, keep a growth mindset, and do whatever it takes to get the job done. We don’t waste time on drama—we stay focused on the mission. Do you rise to challenges with resilience and a clear head?
- Do you consistently push through discomfort to deliver results?

- We’re All In : We carry the mission in our hearts and act like owners. We take full responsibility, build capacity in ourselves and others, and do the work that matters most. Are you passionate about transforming lives and communities through your work?
- Do you take initiative and show up fully—because you believe this mission is worth it?

We don’t hire just for talent. We hire for alignment, character, and commitment to the mission. Expect honest conversations about these values throughout the hiring process.

ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES

The Development Relationship Manager will have four primary roles, broken down into key responsibilities. They are:

1. CREATE & MANAGE THE DONOR PIPELINE

Build, maintain, and manage the donor pipeline, ensuring every donor has a clear path for engagement, cultivation, stewardship, and renewal.

- Maintain the donor pipeline and tracking systems to monitor donor engagement, renewal status, giving history, and cultivation opportunities.
- Enter and maintain accurate donation records in DRM, including processing donations and reconciling donor records.
- Assign and track donor cultivation and engagement tasks in Salesforce.
- Partner with leadership to develop, implement, and manage individualized donor engagement and cultivation plans.
- Track donor giving cycles, identify renewal opportunities, and coordinate timely follow-up.
- Maintain dashboards and reports tracking donor activity, renewals, upgrades, and engagement.

2. MANAGE DONOR STEWARDSHIP & COMMUNICATIONS

Ensure donors feel valued, recognized, informed, and connected to the mission through consistent and personalized stewardship.

- Manage donor acknowledgments, thank-you letters, tax receipts, and personalized thank-you cards.
- Oversee annual donor appreciation and thank-you initiatives.
- Provide responsive donor customer service, addressing questions and resolving giving issues.
- Collaborate with the CEO and Marketing team to develop donor letters, emails, and other donor-facing communications.
- Coordinate donor renewal communications and personalized stewardship messages.
- Ensure donor records, giving histories, and communication records are accurate and up to date.

3. COORDINATE DONOR CULTIVATION & RENEWALS

Coordinate donor engagement and renewal activities that strengthen relationships and encourage continued investment in the mission.

- Manage donor renewal plans and the referral process, and coordinate timely follow-up throughout the year.
- Work with leadership to identify donors who need additional cultivation, engagement, or renewal conversations.
- Schedule donor meetings and prepare leadership and designated Closers with relevant donor information and relationship history.
- Track follow-up and ensure next steps are completed following donor meetings and asks.
- Partner with leadership to execute individualized donor cultivation strategies.
- Collaborate with Executive Directors to steward and engage community board members and strengthen their connection to the mission.

4. PLAN & MANAGE DONOR CULTIVATION EVENTS

Coordinate donor cultivation and stewardship events that deepen relationships and create meaningful opportunities for donors to connect with the mission and leadership.

- Manage donor cultivation and stewardship activities associated with fundraising galas, donor receptions, and special events.
- Coordinate donor invitations, attendance tracking, recognition, and personalized follow-up.
- Partner with leadership and Executive Directors to identify donors and prospects for event engagement.
- Develop and execute cultivation strategies before, during, and after events.
- Manage donor appreciation receptions and other annual donor engagement initiatives.

REQUIREMENTS

- Minimum of 3 years of experience in donor relations, development, or fundraising, with a demonstrated ability to manage donor pipelines and support donor renewal and retention efforts.
- Strong writing and communication skills, with the ability to develop clear, compelling, and personalized donor communications.
- Ability to analyze giving data, segment donors, track results, and maintain reporting dashboards.
- Experience with donor databases and CRM systems (Salesforce, Basecamp, or similar platforms preferred).
- Strong relationship-building, organizational, and follow-through skills, with the ability to collaborate effectively with Closers, Connectors, leadership, and board members.
- Bachelor’s degree (preferred/required).
- Alignment with Better Together’s mission, vision, and core values.

TIMING, LOCATION AND COMPENSATION

Better Together seeks to fill this position as soon as possible. The organization’s headquarters are in Naples, Florida, but all the Better Together staff reside in Florida. Better Together has built a highly successful work culture over the past decade with systems and structures designed for clarity, flexibility, and great communication. Key elements of the environment include:

- Weekly team meetings with clear accountability and the opportunity to solve issues as a team. 
- Quarterly in-person team meetings at which you’ll build deeper relationships, set clear goals aligned with the Better Together vision, and brainstorm how to seize new opportunities
- An intensive 90-day orientation to familiarize you with the Better Together team, our policies, and how we operate
- Home office setup, including equipment and communication tools you need to hit the ground running

Compensation and Benefits:

Better Together offers also offers a generous benefits package, as outlined below:

- Medical (99% employer paid, employee only)
- Dental 
- Vision
- Life Insurance
- Paid Holidays
- Paid Time off
- Retirement Savings Plan with 50/50 employer match up to 6%

QUESTIONS

Please direct all questions to [email protected] .